cross-posted from: https://kbin.social/m/RedditMigration/t/233339
Comments from the original poster:
Not much else needs to be said tbh. Fuck Spez. // Edit: Not sure why imgur marked the album as NSFW, but there’s nothing NSFW in it other than the name of one of the mods including the word “removed”
Personal comment: the critter isn’t even dead but the vultures are already flying in circles around it. I certainly do not envy their situation, I bet that the users will treat them like shit.
Not necessarily. A hash of the body/url+timestamp would always point to the same place, and could be calculated on the fly.
So every comment and post would have a calculation and entry into a table, and this would be done by every instance every time one instance creates a new comment or post? That sounds like a massive unnecessary overhead.
Just use the same ID across all instances. Hell, they could just do https://inst.ance/post/[email protected]
This is redundant but is better than the uuid thing, even though it’s redundant.
I love how your use of the word redundant demonstrated redundancy.
I still think a table and extra processing is wasteful and uneccesary. Rather, instances should just do what they do with communities and users.
The host instance decides the number. Remote instances use that number followed by @instance. This already fits in with the federated model, as posts are always on the community’s local instance originally, and comments are always on the user’s local instance originally.
If you’re on lemmy.one and reply to a post in a community in lemmy.world, that post should be lemmy.world’s number @lemmy.world, then your comment should be lemmy.one’s number @lemmy.one, rather than each instance picking its own sequential number for both.
This kind of thing would probably be the easiest change to implement while requiring minimal server overhead.
For a specific example, to me, this post is https://lemm.ee/post/1726780. In the original, federated instance, the post is https://lemmy.ml/post/2308622. Instead, it should appear to me as https://lemm.ee/post/[email protected].
Your comment, to me, is https://lemm.ee/comment/1409174. The federated link is https://lemmy.one/comment/1393053. This is the link you see, and should continue to see, but I should see https://lemm.ee/comment/[email protected].
Using the instance in the numbering scheme means each federated host instance manages its own numbering while ensuring there will never be a clash between instances. https://lemm.ee/comment/[email protected] and https://lemm.ee/comment/1393053 would refer to two completely different comments. This information is already being transmitted in the process of federation, so it’s just a matter of tagging the data when it’s received.